Mascara | Clean Cosmetics

All Clean Cosmetics

Eyeliners

Facial Serums

Eyelash Growth

Anti-Aging Solutions
Filter Right
4 products
Best sellingAlphabetically, A-ZAlphabetically, Z-APrice, low to highPrice, high to lowDate, old to newDate, new to old

Filter

Out of stock
Price
Down
$
$
Product type
Down
Brand
Down
Sort by
Down
Gentle Eye-Friendly Mascaras

Finding a mascara that’s safe for sensitive eyes, dry eye sufferers, or contact lens wearers can be tough. Many traditional formulas contain harsh chemicals, parabens, and fragrances that cause irritation, redness, and dryness. Our Optometrist Curated Collection features clean, hypoallergenic formulas  — designed to protect eye health while delivering beautiful, flake-free results.

Why Choose Our Sensitive Eye Mascaras?

  • Free from parabens, fragrance, and irritating preservatives

  • Non-irritating and safe for dry eyes and allergies

  • Flake-free and smudge-resistant

  • Easy to remove, no tugging or drying

Gentle, Eye Care Professional-Approved Formulas

Explore our collection of optometrist, ophtalmologist and eye care professional developed brands like Eyes Are the Story, Twenty Twenty Beauty, and We Love Eyes — and get the lash definition you love without the discomfort.

Left Right Quick buy
Èyes Are The Story
ÈYES ARE THE STORY™ | Eye Proof Mascara (Trio Set)
$49.99
Left Right Quick buy
twenty / twenty beauty
Twenty / Twenty Beauty Clean Sweep Mascara
$36.99
Only 7 left!
Left Right Quick buy
Zorah
Zorah Length & Care Mascara
$28.00
Only 5 left!
Left Right Quick buy
We Love Eyes
WE LOVE EYES Lashfull Thinking™ BLACK Pressed Serum Mascara with Widelash™
$77.99

Mascara | Clean Cosmetics FAQ

What makes a mascara safe for sensitive eyes or dry eye disease?

A gentle mascara will be fragrance-free, ophthalmologist-tested, and free of harsh preservatives like parabens. Our mascaras are designed to avoid flaking and smudging, reducing the risk of irritation or tear film disruption.

Can I wear mascara with dry eyes or contact lenses?

Yes—if you choose eye-friendly formulas like the ones in our collection. Look for non-migrating mascaras that stay in place without entering the eye.

How do I remove mascara without irritating my eyes?

Use a gentle, oil-free eye makeup remover or micellar water and a soft cotton pad. Avoid rubbing the lashes to protect both eyes and skin. We have many to choose from in our Eyelid Hygiene collections.